John Scheideman

Leave Bonds alone

Departing from gospel music briefly to address another burning issue in another pastime of mine, sports...

The time is drawing closer when another long time, hallowed sports record is about to be broken.

Namely, the baseball record for all-time home runs, officially held by one of baseball's undisputed all time greats, Hank Aaron.

It may be the all-time major league record, but it is not the alltime professional record.

That would be held by Japan's Sadaharu Oh, who hit over 800 home runs in his long career in the land of the Rising Sun.

But the records held in the American major leagues are the accepted standard for players to shoot at. And besides, neither Aaron nor Barry Bonds ever played in Japanese professional leagues.

No, I'm speaking of Bonds' chase of Aaron's record, which heading into this weekend he is only two shy of tying and three away from breaking.

Under normal circumstances, the majority of the nation's baseball fans would be rooting madly for Bonds to smash the record ASAP.

But these are not normal circumstances. Why?

Because of a widely held belief, propped up by most sports media who have personal axes to grind with Bonds, that Bonds is a "cheater"...i.e., that he hasn't gotten to where he is fairly.

Why is that? Because Bonds is almost a media poster boy for excessive steroid use. People look at the young Bonds of the early 1990s with the Pittsburgh Pirates, young and relatively lean and not putting up huge home run numbers, and compare him to the Bonds of today, considerably larger and probably stronger, and certainly a player that has hit with unprecedented power totals for the last decade or so, and conclude that to hit home runs the way he has of late, that he must have done something unethical or illegal to do so.

Is there proof of that? Unless you cite some leaked testimony to a grand jury where Bonds admitted to having used two brands of steroids(although claiming to not know what they did or were for), which CANNOT be admitted as evidence in a court of law, there is none. Bonds has yet to fail a drug test.

Besides, even if one concedes that he did use steroids at that time, there's still no proof of Bonds "cheating" even then. Consider....

1. That at that time, steroids were not illegal in baseball. They and other supplements were all over the place...just ask Mark McGwire.

2. Most baseball experts say that the major reason Bonds hits for such power is his quick swing, and his unparalleled eye/hand coordination....neither of which are benefitted by the use of steroids. You'd think if Bonds were trying to "cheat", he'd use something that would directly help him hit home runs.

3. All the games Bonds has played in were under the governing rules of baseball at the time they were played. If there was a real rule violation, opposing managers would have played those games under protest, and a ruling would have been made on the protest according to the rules of baseball. No manager or opposing team official ever tried to get games that Bonds played in forfeited. Therefore, the home runs Bonds hit in those games are legitimate, and deserve to be recognized as such.

4. It is not unusual at all for players to hit for far more power as they age. In the case of Hank Aaron, his most productive home run years were after he reached the age of 35. It is more common than not for older players to hit for more power after their other skills go away with age. Another example...Reggie Jackson, who, when he was young, not only hit for power, but had dazzling speed, and was a first-rate outfielder. By the time Jackson ended his career with the Angels, all he could do was hit the occasional home run.

So how did Bonds cheat, exactly?

I don't know...and if Bonds' vociferous critics were honest, they'd admit they don't know either. Like many of us who grew up with an earlier generation of players, their successors just weren't as good as the people we like.(This line of reasoning stretches into gospel music as well!). I grew up with the likes of Aaron, Willie Mays, and Mickey Mantle...and what you hear from many is that if Bonds had to play baseball under the conditions that those other men did, he would not even be close to their achievements.

Maybe...maybe not. But we can't know that, can we? What we do know is that Bonds is playing now, and that now he is only two short of Aaron's record.

There is a lot of personal resentment of Bonds...based on his surly and rude attitude toward some of those in the media whose job it is to report on him, and to some fans as well on occasion. I can't argue with that, or defend Bonds for being unnecessarily rude.

But you know what? Bonds has lots of predecessors in that regard. Babe Ruth was often loud, profane, tacky, and drunk! The great Ted Williams hated sportswriters...I wish I could quote the joke he told about them once, but I can't use those kinds of words in this blog...and I don't normally use them anyway. Ty Cobb was a racist and a thug during games, sometimes trying to injure players deliberately to win games.

So Bonds gets annoyed sometimes when sports reporters press him for answers about his steroid use, or why he's not more friendly. Don't WE do that sometimes? I don't know about you, but I admit I do!

Let's face it...Barry Bonds is an all-too-human being who is good at hitting home runs, and has hit more of them than any major league baseball player except for Hank Aaron, and that will change before this season is over.

Many baseball fans don't like that, but guess what...life is full of things we don't like.

As for Barry Bonds, until it is PROVEN that he has "cheated", accept his accomplishments, and deal with it!

Posted on Jul 21, 2007 - 01:32 AM | [6] Comments | Misc | Permalink

Page 1 of 1 pages

Comments

Page 1 of 1 Comment Pages

Hey, John,

I'm afraid that Barry did the damage to himself and it's already done. There is no way that men bulk up like he has (not around the belly) without the help of steroids. In my mind, he cheated. His record will never hold have credibility for me and probably millions of other baseball fans.

I'll never forget a comment I heard Mickey Mantle make. He said that if the players back n the 50 s and 60s knew that hitting homeruns was important, they would have all hit a lot more. Bulking up for the purpose of getting stats just cheapens the stats. I feel the same way about the record being broken with a longer schedule. Records need to all be made on the same playing field.

Stepping from my soapbox..... OK, I can feel Spiritual again.... LOL


Commented by Deon Unthank On 07/22/2007

John Scheideman's avatar But Deon, you didn't read my entry closely enough.

If you consider the points I raised, then HOW did steroids help Bonds "cheat"(assuming he actually used them as people claim?? And given the rules in existence at the time Bonds is alleged to have used steroids, how did he "cheat"?

I always thought cheating was when you broke rules, not necessarily operating within the rules to gain an advantage for yourself.

Riddle me that.

Morning glory and evening grace,

Giving the world a smile each day,

john.sogospelnews.com



Commented by On 07/22/2007

John, that's why I said "in my mind" he cheated. When Ruth, Mantle, Musial and the like were playing ball and hitting homeruns, they were just playing baseball. They didn't do anything to their bodies for the purpose of trying to hit homeruns to break any record. McGuire, Bonds, Conseco, and the like have altered their bodies for that purpose. Sorry, but in my mind it's not the same. Legal or not, to it it's cheating.
In the same way, when Roger Maris broke Ruth's record, he had more games to do it in, it was not a fair comparison. It's the same difference to me.
Maybe we should have two record books. One for non-steroids and one for steroids. Then we're on level footing.
When JD Sumner made the record for the lowest note, if someone had an operation and altered their vocal chords so that they could hit a lower note, that would be cheating to me. That's the same way I see this.


Commented by Deon Unthank On 07/22/2007

John Scheideman's avatar But Deon, you have no way of knowing how many steroids Bonds took, or even if he took them. Other than his grand jury admission, there's no record of him doing that...he never failed a drug test.

Second, you also have no way of knowing that if he did, WHY he did, unless he told you...and I'm betting he never confided in you any of his motives.

And as far as people "just playing baseball", what game is Bonds playing out there, anyway? Last I checked, the San Francisco Giants were a baseball team...even though some in the Bay Area may argue that...lol

My point remains, unless you can specifically point out what Bonds is doing that's cheating(for baseball record purposes violating the rules of the sport), and prove it, stop complaining about what he's doing and recognize his accomplishments for what they are. You don't have to like them.

And as for the Maris comparison, baseball got rid of the asterisk a long time ago.

Morning glory and evening grace,

Giving the world a smile each day,

john.sogospelnews.com



Commented by On 07/22/2007

John,you're getting a little legalistic on me here. Look at the guy. Look at the others who admitted taking steroids, and look at the ones who did that say that Bonds took steroids. Again, "in my mind" there is enough reasonable doubt to make that judgment call. If I see a strange guy sneaking around a window with a screw driver in his hand it doesn't take much to figure out that he is a burglar.

I think you know what I meant by "just playing baseball". They weren't out trying to break records, they were just playing the game.

I don't have to be able to prove3 that he is or was taking steroids to make a reasonable judgment about Bonds. Maybe you can be happy with a record set thi9s way, but it drives me buggy. It may be in the record books, but it will be insignificant to me. Much the same why that they may have taken the asterisk away from Maris' numbers, but there is still a difference to me and a lot of other baseball fans.

If you like it, celebrate it, I just won't be jumping in the streets with you. It will be more like a yawn for me.


Commented by Deon Unthank On 07/22/2007

John Scheideman's avatar Deon, let me sum up what I tried to say from my post(for you and anyone else interested).

My only point was that Bonds is getting assailed from all sides for his alleged "cheating"(which no one has proven to this point)...and the criticism of Bonds is so mean-spirited(even on the sports talk show I'm listening to now)that it disturbs my sensibilities...especially since Bonds has done nothing to merit such stupid, uninformed, personal criticism.

Nothing Barry Bonds has done has really hurt the game of baseball...it keeps on going...and to take every possible occasion to spout vitriol and self-righteous resentment against someone who happens to be on the verge of breaking a major record in the sport(just because they don't like the man and resort to any urban legend to justify it)is a sad commentary on what sports fans have become, and how jaded many of us has gotten.

BTW, Deon, none of the above applies to you...let me stress that.

But you can't just say "Look at him" and cite the anonymous quotes of other(jealous?)ballplayers, or people who "know" Bonds. Those "legalisms" you refer to are called "rights"...and guess what...all of us have them, and it's easy for some of us to dismiss the rights of those we don't care for, while whining and screaming about it when we perceive that our own rights are being violated.

As for Maris, he encountered similar baseless resentment in 1961 when he pursued Ruth's single season home run record. People forget that Maris wasn't some nobody challenging an immortal...he was the American League MVP the year before(as he would be that year as well)! The stress Maris felt as a result took its' toll on the remainder of his career, even though he played right field for two more World Series champions in the late 1960s.

And what about Aaron? He went through tremendous personal stress in the days before he set the current record, from racists who would not stomach the idea that someone like Aaron would dare break the Babe's record.

I feel no pity for Bonds, Deon, because as you said, he brought a lot of this on himself because of his demeanor and arrogance, but the plain facts are that his records are legitimate according to all the rules of baseball, and as should be the case with anyone on the verge of achieving excellence, they should receive just recognition for their achievements.

No, I won't be celebrating in the streets either when Bonds breaks the record...I'm neither a Bonds fan nor a Giants' fan...but I won't turn up my nose and sneer, either. Barry Bonds will be the all-time major league home run leader in a short while, and baseball fans who care just need to deal with that...or at least make a better case than they have to this point.

Morning glory and evening grace,

Giving the world a smile each day,

john.sogospelnews.com



Commented by On 07/23/2007

Page 1 of 1 Comment Pages


Add Comments

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


* Note: Members of Southern Gospel News.com who are logged in do not have to fill in the above information each time they post

By posting you agree to our Comments Policy

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Categories

Archives

Syndicate

Southern Gospel News

Southern Gospel Blogs

Links

Member Login