John Scheideman

Ah, the good old days

I wish I could've bought that book today.

Today, after I took care of all my personal business, I actually had time to go to the Borders bookstore here in town and read through some books...a pastime that, sadly, I haven't had much time for in a while.

One book caught my attention in particular...the title of it escapes me as I type here, but it is a historical account of how Music Row in Nashville evolved, and in the process, how Nashville became "Music City, USA".

The book offered a number of first-hand anecdotes of just how the studios, the publishing companies, and the record labels all came together to make Nashville the #1 force behind recorded music in the last half of the 20th century.

One such first hand profile was of a man who would become a leading A&R man there who cut his musical teeth on the old "All Night Sings" that Wally Fowler used to promote in the 1950s. A lot of the people who would later become major players in the recording industry got interested in music because of the gospel quartets of the 1940s and 1950s.

This gentleman particularly noted the Statesmen and Blackwood Brothers, who he said had "more talent" and stage presence than 90% of the country acts of the day, and he spoke with nostalgic affection about how good they and many of their competitors in gospel music were.

My first reaction after reading all that was, "Why don't people speak that way about gospel artists anymore?"

Now, I realize there is a lot of truly talented people out there today in the gospel field. But it DOES seem that fewer fans of music in general are aware of the talent that's in the gospel genre, especially when you compare what many of the top artists in the general music business were aware of in the gospel field back then. Clearly, that sense of excitement about the best gospel music artists is missing now when compared to what was taking place 40 years ago.

And, to me, that is a sad thing.

I've gotta buy that book the next time I go to Borders.
Posted on Mar 13, 2007 - 11:27 PM | [7] Comments | Southern Gospel Music | Permalink

Page 1 of 1 pages

Comments

Page 1 of 1 Comment Pages

Fascinating post. Would you mind telling us the name of the book? I just might check it out myself.

There is a group out there today performing up to those standards. I know you don't care for the looks on their faces, but it nonetheless remains that they do have a traditional male quartet sound, a highly professional stage presentation, and generate quite a bit of excitement.


Commented by Daniel J. Mount On 03/14/2007

John Scheideman's avatar I'll try to get that title for you as soon as I can, Daniel.

And I know who you're referring to, Daniel, but all hype aside, they as yet have not caused people outside the gospel fan base to react to them in the way the groups of years past got people to react to what THEY did.

If in 30 years it is discovered that a well-known secular artist got interested in music as a vocation as a result of this group's work, I'll be happy to come here and admit there was ONE group in the 00s that caused aspiring musicians to react in that way to them.

I tend to doubt that that will happen, though...and that has NOTHING to do with the looks on their faces whatsoever.

Morning glory and evening grace,

Giving the world a smile each day,

john.sogospelnews.com



Commented by On 03/14/2007

John-

The secret to the excitement of Gospel Music is not the performance, but rather the exciting Good News. We sing the most glorious truths in the universe so why wouldn't they come off as superior to those of the country music field?

Many of the country music songs tell a story like, "Bubba ran off with Nellie, and Cooter's gonna gun him down.!" Sounds like a no-brainer to me.

Neil


Commented by On 03/14/2007

John Scheideman's avatar Neil, thanks for weighing in. I share your point of view regarding the true "secret" of gospel music.

At one point in my life, though, I shared the value system of the unsaved world...and I'm the first to admit that the visceral trappings of the great gospel quartets of yore had a lot to do with "hooking" me onto their music.

Later, when I finally discovered the glorious truth in the lyrics they sang so well, I was able to make more authentic distinctions in my musical(and other personal)tastes.

Still, I give these classic groups credit for attracting me(and others)to a way of life far better than I could have conceived otherwise.

Morning glory and evening grace,

Giving the world a smile each day,

john.sogospelnews.com



Commented by On 03/14/2007

Times change. In the 1950s, there were gospel songs on the pop charts by pop artists. Then the gospel groups would record those songs such as The Man Upstairs, Robe of Calvary and Open Up Your Heart. The top groups apppeared on national TV and radio shows. Some of the gospel groups were on major record labels so the same musicians who played for the pop artists would play for the name gospel groups. (eg. Chet Atkins.) So the name gospel groups were known to musicians and people other than Gospel fans. For a multitude of reasons that is not the case today.


Commented by On 03/14/2007

John Scheideman's avatar Norm, I'm aware of all that.

You've done a good job explaining why the historical context was different 40 years ago...and no doubt all of that contributed to gospel music having more of an impact in the general marketplace back then than it does today.

Maybe I'm just pining that those days left us.

Morning glory and evening grace,

Giving the world a smile each day,

john.sogospelnews.com



Commented by On 03/14/2007

"Many of the country music songs tell a story like, "Bubba ran off with Nellie, and Cooter's gonna gun him down."

There are poorly written and produced country songs but the percentage of poorly written, badly performed gospel songs is certainly much higher than in the country field. Poor product is the #1 problem in Southern Gospel Music.

It's interesting that when country writers decide to write gospel songs, many do it extremely well and sell far more than SGM singers could imagine. Consider songs like Why Me Lord?, Jesus Take the Wheel, One Day at a Time, Three Wooden Crosses and Long Black Train. Those songs show far more creativity than 95 per cent of the SGM songs I hear.


Commented by On 03/14/2007

Page 1 of 1 Comment Pages


Add Comments

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


* Note: Members of Southern Gospel News.com who are logged in do not have to fill in the above information each time they post

By posting you agree to our Comments Policy

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Categories

Archives

Syndicate

Southern Gospel News

Southern Gospel Blogs

Links

Member Login